Skip to main content
Advertising

Instant Debate

Tyrann Mathieu, J.J. Watt among NFL's most versatile defensive players

Since 2012, the Seattle Seahawks have ranked in the top five in overall defense on an annual basis. The star-studded unit is led by the play of Michael Bennett and Cliff Avril in the trenches, Bobby Wagner and K.J. Wright at linebacker and "Legion of Boom" members Richard Sherman, Earl Thomas and Kam Chancellor in the secondary.

One of these versatile players will be revealed on this week's installment of the NFL Network's "Top 100 Players of 2016." This leads to one question: Who is the most versatile defensive player in the NFL?

"Top 100 Players of 2016" airs every Wednesday at 8 p.m. ET on NFL Network until the full list has been revealed. The conversation continues on the "Top 100 Players Reaction" show, which airs immediately after at 9 p.m. ET.

Mathieu has Ed Reed-type safety instincts combined with Kam Chancellor-type tackling security. People are always trying to find a weakness in his game, but there doesn't seem to be one. The Cardinals can use him in so many ways because he's good at all of the things you can't teach, including instincts, recovery speed, vision, etc., which makes him more difficult to game plan for than even Troy Polamalu was. The kid is simply the best out there right now. To no one's surprise, Watt is the most versatile player. When I watch film on him, he can do everything and line up and play any position on the defensive line. Even when he doesn't get to the QB, he's versatile enough to understand throwing lanes -- nobody's batted more balls than Watt. Having that flexibility and versatility has made him even more dangerous as a defender. I have to go with Tyrann Mathieu, but Khalil Mack is a very close second. Mathieu can play across the entire defensive backfield, and I just haven't seen another player who can do that like he can. What makes him really special, though, is his ability to blitz and disrupt plays. He's a huge playmaker for the Cardinals and every time the ball is thrown his way, there's an opportunity for a change of possession. I think teams are starting to look for Mathieu-type players in the draft each year because they see how effective he is. This guy can do it all. He is a cornerback who can blitz, cover a receiver anywhere in the secondary, return punts and possibly could play wide receiver or running back. He has the quickness to do the tough work outside the numbers, but also has the build to go into the bike lane and deal with the banging. There are a lot of guys who can do one or the other, but Peterson can do both. He's a huge talent for the Arizona Cardinals. This is a close one between two teammates, Arizona's Patrick Peterson and Tyrann Mathieu, but I have to go with the safety. Mathieu's ability to cover different positions proves his versatility. He can line up against some of the greatest offensive players in the league, from a dominant Rob Gronkowski to speedster Julio Jones to pass-catching running back Matt Forte. He's able to do so much -- regardless of his small stature -- because of his speed and strength.

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content